Directors’ remuneration includes salary paid to the corporate director, in addition to a corporate director’s other duties that relate to management and governance. The different kinds of compensation provided for these include salary, bonus, commission, stock option and profit-sharing arrangements, among others, all in financial and non-financial terms. A director is the one who sets strategy and outlines company operations while adhering to laws and regulations. This makes their remuneration determined by their duties, performance, and overall contributions to the organisation. In most countries, corporate laws and companies’ policies control the structure and level of remuneration to directors for reasonableness, transparency and consistency with the financial goals. Some types of compensation, particularly those of public companies, require shareholder approval. A well-designed remuneration system makes directors responsive to the needs of the firm and stakeholders and balances risk with sustainable growth. It further attracts and retains capable and seasoned professionals. However, it can give rise to a conflict of interest and governance issue in case the remuneration package is excessively paid or designed improperly. Hence, organisations should carefully craft remuneration packages for directors with a focus on long-term goals and performance to ensure accountability and responsible management.
Modes of Director Remuneration Under Company Law
Private companies under company law, have the authority to decide upon the forms of directors’ remunerations as long as they conform to the Companies Act 2013 in India or the pertinent corporate laws that apply in other countries. The remuneration structure usually appears in the Articles of Association (AoA) of a company and, in most cases, requires board approval and, in some cases, approval from the shareholders. Private companies can create a balanced and appealing compensation package by combining different remuneration elements, which will put the interests of the directors in line with the long-term goals of the organisation. Some methods of director remuneration in a private company are as follows:
- Salary: Whole Time Directors and Managing Directors or Directors who have full-time work within the organisation, engaged in the day-to-day administration of the company are given a fixed remuneration. Remuneration may be paid monthly or quarterly through their employment contract. Along with this remuneration, extra allowances, benefits and perks may be added.
- Sitting Fees: Non executive and independent directors are entitled to receive sitting fees in respect of participating in the Board or committee meetings. Private companies have the discretion to fix their sitting fee, subject to any restrictions imposed by corporate legislation. There is a sitting fee permissible limit in respect of some classes of Indian companies, though private firms are more liberal.
- Commission on Profits: Directors often get a percentage commission on a profit-sharing basis from the company. It motivates directors to add profitability. Commissions on a profit basis are not valid unless approved through articles of association and also allowed by the shareholders or the board of directors of a private concern.
- Perquisites and Allowances: Executive directors may be allowed other benefits, which include housing, company vehicles, medical reimbursements, travel allowances, club memberships and a host of others. These form part of the integrated compensation package.
- Professional/Technical Fees: Directors might be paid differently for professional or technical services delivered outside their responsibilities as directors. This must, however, not conflict with the requirements related to related party transactions, and all disclosure and approvals must be given.
- Bonuses and Incentives: Remuneration can be provided as incentives under a performance management scheme. Commonly, in the private sector, these tend to be set in terms of performance indicators associated with certain specified corporate goals and targets, not to mention benchmark success levels. An important aspect to be taken is that the performance of the board must coincide with the directors’ interests.
- Employee Stock Ownership Plan: Compensation of directors in private companies may also include Employee Stock Ownership Plans or equity shares. Such a compensation system allows the directors to buy company shares at a pre-set price, which becomes a great motivator for the directors to make decisions that contribute to the company’s long-term prosperity. Normally, the issuance of an ESOP is subject to shareholder approval.
- Profit Sharing Compensation: Directors also get profit sharing compensation besides the commissions that come from the company’s net profits. The profit sharing should adhere to corporate law and align with the organisation’s Articles of Association.
- Reimbursement of expenses: All expenses incurred by directors in the course of their duties are entitled to reimbursement, including travel, lodging and other business related expenses. Such reimbursements are not considered compensation but rather an entitlement.
Director Remuneration in a Private Limited Company
Private corporations pay directors compensation to them for their services in different manners. The provisions and determination of directors’ salary are covered under the Companies Act, 2013 and the Articles of Association of the company and mutual agreements among the shareholders. Private corporations have relatively more comfort while structuring directors’ compensation compared with public companies because the statutory restrictions within the remuneration are not too stringent.
This provision actually talks about the remuneration of directors in public companies and their subsidiaries under Section 197 of the Companies Act 2013. However, this is not applicable to private companies that get exemptions under specific conditions, thereby increasing flexibility. In particular, the Companies Amendment Act, 2017 and Exemption Notifications offer much relief to the private entity.
Private companies have the power to decide the procedure and amount of remuneration for directors, as long as it is consistent with their Articles of Association and gets the relevant approval from the Board of Directors or shareholders, depending on the situation.
Approvals Required for Director Remuneration in a Private Company
- Board Approval: The Board of Directors usually approves ordinary remuneration. Remuneration should be in line with the requirements of the company’s Articles of Association.
- Shareholder Approval: Large commissions, bonuses and the issue of options may require the affirmative vote of a resolution from either an ordinary resolution or special resolution at the instance of shareholders. Transparency will enhance this and meet the demands and expectations of shareholder interests
- Requirement of AoA: The Articles of Association impose restrictions and limitations on what one can have pertaining to a director’s remuneration; in the absence thereof, shareholders pass a special or ordinary resolution amendment to add requirements for that precise remuneration.
Privately owned corporations, especially those not subsidiaries of a publicly traded firm, have the following exemptions:
- They are not subject to the 11% salary cap for managerial posts in public firms.
- A private corporation, unlike a public company, may pay higher wages without having the need to file for government permission under specific circumstances.
- Fewer requirements of directors’ salaries regarding disclosure and compliance exist in private corporations.
Key Considerations When Structuring the Remuneration of Directors
Aligning director remuneration with long-term company objectives can really motivate the director. A transparent and fair pay structure would alleviate any conflict of interest situations likely to arise during the payment mechanism. Compliance is also critical under legal standards that include corporate, tax and accounting requirements of remuneration. Performance Incentives; linking compensation to performance incentives can promote effective contributions by the directors. To avoid conflicts of interest, it is important to take proper care with the related party transactions so as not to misbehave.
If there is non compliance with the statutes of director’s remuneration, the private corporation and directors may suffer a penalty and fines. For major contraventions, the directors can be disqualified. Tax deduction and declaration may also result in penalties.
Private corporations thus have to pay due care while structuring and reporting their director’s remuneration. The private firm allows considerable flexibility in both design and amount for director remuneration. This could include salary, bonuses, profit-sharing, stock options, and other benefits targeted at rewarding the directors for strategic input and leadership. Although private corporations face fewer regulatory restrictions than public companies, they should ensure that transparency is maintained, obtain all necessary approvals, and fulfil the legal and tax requirements. A well-structured compensation framework aligns the interests of the directors with growth and sustainability while ensuring accountability and good governance.
Taxability of Director Remuneration under a Private Limited Company
The remuneration of directors in a private limited company varies according to the nature of the remuneration and the position of the director. All these salaries, commissions and benefits of the executive directors fall under the category of income from salary, which requires the company to withhold TDS under Section 192. However, if a non-executive director gets sitting fees, professional fees or commissions, he is treated as income from other sources or business, with TDS under Section 194J. When a director renders professional services, the compensation is considered consultancy income and gets taxed accordingly. Stock options are taxed as perquisites at exercise, and any profits arising thereafter will attract capital gains tax. Reimbursement of genuine business expenses is tax-free if lawful and reasonably related to the business, though salaries and sitting fees do not attract GST in general but may attract it in professional services. The company needs to perform TDS computation accurately, and report quarterly returns together with compliance towards tax reporting liabilities.
Conclusion
The compensation package of directors of a private limited company plays a strategic role in ensuring the attraction and retention of talented leaders to manage and lead the organisation. The pay package is quite flexible, such that private companies can customise remunerations according to the role or responsibilities of the director or his performance. Directors could be paid by way of different forms of remuneration, including salaries, bonuses, sitting fees, commissions, stock options and other additional benefits, which are all treated differently under existing income tax rules. Therefore, directors need to adhere to tax legislation, such as TDS deduction, GST and accurate accounting, to avoid penalties and increase transparency. Although private companies enjoy more freedom to determine remuneration compared to public companies, they should make sure compensation is fair, congruent with the corporate objective and meets the legal standard. In essence, a good pay system will drive directors to be responsible for driving the company forward while maintaining corporate governance responsibility.
Related Services
